March 28, 2024, 03:13:15 PM

News:

"Welcome to WiseWomenUnite.com -- When adult children marry and leave home, life can sometimes get more complex instead of simpler.  Being a mother-in-law or daughter-in-law can be tough.  How do we extend love and support to our mothers-in-law, adult children, daughters-in-law, sons-in-law, and grandchildren without interfering?  What do we do when there are communication problems?  How can we ask for help when we need it without being a burden?  And how do our family members feel about these issues?  We invite you to join our free forum, read some posts... and when you're ready...share your challenges and wisdom."


Expectations too High?

Started by worrysome, January 06, 2014, 04:37:58 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

worrysome

My concern is with my DS, lives in another state, married <10 yrs.> with toddler and one on the way.  DIL is a stay at home mom.  Home life includes DIL expressing violent rages almost every month that make no logical sense, alternating with periods when DIL acts perfectly normal and loving, of which, I have observed three rages, one being directed at me.  My feelings are my DS may be experiences battered husband syndrome.  Most the time, he doesn't engage her during these fights, keeps quiet, but has been baited into fights where he gets hurt, or he pushes her to get away from her.  OK, this is not the issue (another post maybe). 
Because he is under so much stress, he forgets things (keys, credit cards, important dates).  The reason for this post is he forgets to thank people for gift from family members - Grandparents, brother and mom (me).  This has been happening for a couple of years and this was not how he was raised.  The latest episode deals with this Xmas.  My expectation is to call after opening gift.  The call came on the normal Sunday phone call (4 days after receipt – tracked box with signature).  Calls to Grandparent (GP) and brother had not been made yet for Xmas gift.  DIL will occasionally call with a thank you when 'she likes' what she received...sometimes not.  However, will thank on normal Sunday phone call, if asked if received.
On Sunday call, DS thanked for gifts, asked what was wrong and I replied, 'what do you think is wrong?'  He acknowledged he hadn't thanked me, and said he was sorry.  I guess I wasn't very excepting of his apology, so he quickly put DIL on the phone.  She thanked for the gifts, and I had to ask about specific gifts (did they fit, etc.).  During our conversation, she reminded DS to call GP & brother.  So I knew they hadn't been thanked either.  After several minutes talking about GD, I asked to talk to DS.  I asked him if he had thanked GP & brother and he started to make excuses but said would do so after we talked.
In our conversation, I told DS that I would be getting my own cell phone plan.  We have an arrangement that they include me on their 'family cell plan', and my payment comes out of expenses for helping them move, helping them decorate their home and making items for their home.  I pay for all the expenses associated with these projects.  In our conversation, he asked why I wanted to change.  I asked him how much this costs per month, and he stated around $15.  I shared a feeling that I wondered if this costs was being applied to: mother's day, birthday and Xmas.  He didn't reply, so I ended the conversation with I love you and please call your GP and brother. 
I know DS was feeling dejected and I didn't feel any better after the call.  So I wrote my feelings down and sent him an email.  I will paraphrase my comments:
•   I told him I love him, and always will, no matter what the circumstances are or will be.  Often times, we hurt the ones closest to us.  I told him I was hurt and disappointed by his actions;
•   Family members feel you don't care or appreciate "our giving';
•   The expectation is to call as soon as you open the gift, otherwise, you forget. I shared, I knew he didn't intentionally do this but it doesn't diminish the 'hurt' feelings it creates";
•   I didn't understand not receiving a Xmas gift – did he just forget?
•   I told him I wasn't mad at him, just hurt, and was not writing this to make him feel less than a man, or to hurt him.  Communication is the key to working out our situation;
•   I asked him to call so we could talk this through....told him "Family is EVERYTHING!!  We are your support system and you need us, as we need you".

Now I'm not sure if I was too hard on him and pushed too much?  Maybe my expectations are too high but this has been the course for the last two years.

Sarah

Wait..I'm so sorry..did I read this right?  He has one toddler and one on the way and you are upset he didn't thank everyone for gifts and you guilt him and email him and take him to task for this?  IMO, you are pushing him away.  He is a grown man with responsibilities.  Should he thank family members?  Yes, but that is not up to you to dictate.  imo, this is not a battle I would choose to have with my son.  Good luck.

jdtm

QuoteExpectations too High?

This post may seem harsh - not meant to be so - as I have lived what you are now living.  When our children get married, I learned that the immediate family unit includes the spouse and the children (our precious grandchildren). My immediate family includes my spouse (if one is lucky to have one); and if we  are lucky enough, good friends.  The part that that I found hard to "get" is that my husband and I are now "extended" family.  But that comes with lessened stress and work and expense - the immediate family is responsible for those things (and whether or not they say "thank you"; of course, we get to decide whether or not we give - gifts, money, babysitting, etc.).  And, I find that my husband and I give less and less - partly due to our age, our children's/grandchildren's ages, and the gratitude expressed/not expressed.

As Luise often says that our expectations are fair and reasonable; however, no one (and that includes our adult children) need meet them.  I am now finding this to be true with our elderly parents - what they expect cannot be met by my husband and/or me.  I agree with you that "communication is the key"; but I often find that no communication is the answer (and we don't see or hear from our adult children as much as we would like; the reverse is also true, we don't call or visit our elderly parents as much as they would like).

QuoteNow I'm not sure if I was too hard on him and pushed too much?  Maybe my expectations are too high but this has been the course for the last two years.

What's that old saying - insanity is doing things the same way and expecting different results?  I found that "backing off" was the best course of action for us, and in doing so, I am in less contact with our adult children but I have far, far more activities and friends and happy times without them.  I guess I have just "let go".

Life is not fair and certainly often not what we want or deserve.  But, life can still be very good.  So sorry for your pain ....

Pen

Worrysome, we ask all new members to please read the pink-highlighted items under Open Me First on the home page. You will learn how the site started, what the policies are, and you can decide whether or not this site is a good fit for you.

That said, I must agree that you do have high expectations, IMO. Please keep reading old posts to glean wisdom from our experiences. Most of the time backing off has worked better than pushing our DSs.

Respect ... is appreciation of the separateness of the other person, of the ways in which he or she is unique.
-- Annie Gottlieb

Pooh

January 07, 2014, 08:46:41 AM #4 Last Edit: January 07, 2014, 08:48:14 AM by Pooh
The one thing we learn around here is that our expectations are exactly that.  They are our expectations.  They may be reasonable or unreasonable, but either way, they belong to us and not the other person(s).  Although I will agree I think that anyone should be thanked for a gift, I've never had the expectation that I needed to be thanked immediately upon opening.  If I'm reading correctly, he thanked you on your normal Sunday phone call that fell after they opened the gifts from Christmas?  The other side too is that although I'd like to think my Son has manners, I'm not responsible for telling him to thank other people.  He's an adult and that's his responsibility and between him and the other adults.

I also know it's hurtful for him not to send you a gift, but again, that's your expectation to receive one.  Maybe they didn't have the money and couldn't buy for anyone?  Or maybe they did think that since they pay your cell phone that was a gift in itself?  This is just me, but when it comes to gifts, I never expect one from anyone.  I spent quite a bit on YS/DIL and GS, and they bought me and DH about a $10 item each.  I was very grateful for that little item, because I know they struggle as a young couple and for them to even get us anything was super nice of them.  They were told beforehand not to even buy for us and save their money.  I'm in a place I can afford to provide them with nice gifts, they are not.  When gifts become a competition, I think the spirit of the gift loses it's meaning.
We must let go of the life we have planned, so as to accept the one that is waiting for us. -
Joseph Campbell

hairstylist

I have to agree with the other ladies, your expectations are high. I know from personal experience from my MIL expecting my DH to do what she expected him to do, like come to every family function (not caring about my family), buy everyone Christmas gifts (not caring that we just got married and paid for a wedding) and etc. has caused a lot of problems between the two of them, also in our marriage with us fighting and bickering at each other about her. Because she has thought she could tell her grown son what to do they aren't close anymore. I'm sure that she thinks this is all my fault but in reality she caused it.
Try to step back and let your son do his own thing. Since family is everything for you guys try asking what is bothering him instead of just assuming it is the DIL. They may have money issues, job issues, is the baby on the way healthy.

worrysome

Sorry if I posted something wrong.  My intent was to reach out to this community to help me solve this problem, the one I created. 

That said, thank you for the advice shared.  The posts are not too harsh.  I want your honest opinion. 

New posts are always welcome and encouraged.  I will use it to help me!  Sometimes, we are too close to the situation to really see what we are doing. 

Footloose

Oh Worry,
My expectations have exceeded reality at times too!  Stay with us and soak up the experiences and recommendations here.  you are among friends!

Presents and thanks yous are your traditions and priority but obviously not your son's? He has a right to chose his own for himself and new family.  I try to look at it this way instead of pushing my opinions of what is right.  It's not a matter of right vs wrong, it's simply a difference in preferences, like chocolate and vanilla.  The "right" answer is the individual's preference....

Welcome! hugs!

jdtm

QuoteSorry if I posted something wrong.

Worrysome - you did not post anything wrong.  Practically every one of us could have written your posting when we first joined.  If only DILs (or SILs) came with instruction booklets.  What we expect is fair and just and reasonable; unfortunately, others do not have to be fair and just and reasonable (even our own children).  By the way, I don't think you (or your son) created any problem; it's just that things change when our children get married (and I believe more so with sons than daughters) and no one tells us!  One day we are of utmost importance in our children's lives and the next - well, in my case, I became non-existent/invisible.   We get to figure this out for ourselves and no one made more errors than I did.  All I did was create a lot of anguish - mostly for me.

As Footloose said - you are among friends and "welcome". 

FAFE

Ha!  Our own children do not come with directions, so why should we (that word again) expect our in-laws to come with directions either.  Not making light of the subject or a response, but have said that same thing to my children many times - you did not come with directions, I have done the best I know how.  I would die for you, but I have had to wing it to get you where you are.

Cranky Pants

Quote from: FAFE on January 07, 2014, 03:57:06 PM
Ha!  Our own children do not come with directions, so why should we (that word again) expect our in-laws to come with directions either.  Not making light of the subject or a response, but have said that same thing to my children many times - you did not come with directions, I have done the best I know how.  I would die for you, but I have had to wing it to get you where you are.

This is some serious wisdom, thank you so much for posting this, I too, have done the best I know how although things haven't worked out the way I hoped.

CP

Pen

Quote from: worrysome on January 07, 2014, 09:41:46 AM
Sorry if I posted something wrong.  My intent was to reach out to this community to help me solve this problem, the one I created. 

That said, thank you for the advice shared.  The posts are not too harsh.  I want your honest opinion. 

New posts are always welcome and encouraged.  I will use it to help me!  Sometimes, we are too close to the situation to really see what we are doing.

Oh, you didn't post anything wrong! I'm sorry if my welcome sounded like a scolding :( I try to mix up my wording when welcoming newbies so it doesn't sound rote, but this time I think it came out as a criticism. Again, sorry...and welcome!

I too had expectations, although in my own mind they were very reasonable, lol. I've learned to scale back.
Respect ... is appreciation of the separateness of the other person, of the ways in which he or she is unique.
-- Annie Gottlieb

DixieDarling

Judging from what you've told us about your son and his family he is probably doing his best. If indeed his wife is having some emotional issues (Which if one is on the way may explain some of that with hormones etc) along with a toddler , job, home etc, etc.
You may be the only source he has where he don't have to be perfect? Honestly he sounds like he could use a huge hug.

worrysome

Thank you, all, for making me feel welcome.  A hug is what I needed. 

Footloose, your wisdom is WISE!

FAFE, I guess I should share this thought with my DSs; it would make me more "human" and one who makes mistakes.  I think our choices were the best we could do at the time.  Your comments made me chuckle, no disrespect intended, as my mom has said this to me.  The chuckle is the realization that I have become my mother.  She shares her expectations when it comes to giving, especially for gifts of money.  I am always grateful, and call as soon as I get the gift (her expectation).  I hear when my children don't thank her.  So my reaction is to share this with DS.  She is the type that will stop giving and the outcome is hurt for the DS who didn't follow her expectation. 

DixieDarling, I know my DS is doing the best he can.  And I have to honestly say DIL is doing the best she can.  I need to do more research to help me understand the rage issues (quote from DS).  I don't know how I should respond when I witness this behavior.  Any insight?

I feel my DS is experiencing what he feels is judgment from me.  All I can do is pray that he will be able to look past this and keep me in his life.

FAFE

WS, there is a funny thing going around on Facebook that reads "Life does not come with a manual - It comes with a Mother.  (Hope this is not inappropriate to share here.)  Your son is a grown person, who was taught to say thank you for gifts, etc.  I think I would never, ever remind him again to thank someone for a gift.  if it results in him not getting any more presents, then so be it.  If he's really interested in getting presents and saying thank you is the key, then he will make changes.  When he was little it was appropriate for you to encourage and maybe suggest hardily that he did the thank you notes, calls, etc.  Pick your battles and let this one go.  Here's another hug.