Author Topic: Advice needed - Future daughter-in-law is allowing contact only via her  (Read 7090 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Keys Girl

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 319
  • photo courtesy of Suat Eman
    • View Profile
Re: Advice needed - Future daughter-in-law is allowing contact only via her
« Reply #60 on: August 01, 2010, 07:58:24 AM »
I sense a lot of pain from you posts.  Behind all the toughness and ruggedness, there is a person that is vulnerable and that has been hurt a lot. I am sorry for the injustice that has happened to you. I am glad to see however that you know you are able to take good care of yourself.
I think it was your absolute right to refuse to pay for the ring or pitch in for the wedding and that your decision ought to have been respected. You have done all your best bringing up your child and he is responsible for himself now.

As for the ultimatum, I agree with 1Glitterati. Ultimatums only work if you follow through completely and you have let go of the outcome. Meaning that you will be able to accept whatever the outcome will be.
Life is not black and white, people are not black and white and all-or-nothing approach can leave us soon lonely. To set the consequences for unacceptable behavior is completely ok and can also be done in other ways.

For instance:

If you break your plans with me by not showing up or by calling me at the last minute to tell me that you had something else come up, I will confront your behavior and share my feelings. If you repeat that behavior, I will consider it to mean that you do not value or deserve my friendship - and I will have no contact with you for a month.

Since behavior patterns are quite ingrained in all of us, it is important to allow the other person some wiggle room to make a change in behavior - unless the behavior is really intolerable.  To go from one extreme to the other is a reaction to a reaction - and is codependent.  There are choices in between which are sometimes hard for us to see if we are reacting.  It is helpful to set boundaries that allow for some gradual change.

The consequences we set down for behavior we find unacceptable should be realistic - in that, the change that we are asking for is something that is within the others power (rather they are willing to take that responsibility is another thing altogether) - and enforceable, something that we are willing to do.

I read you have decided not to share your vulnerabilities with them, have no contact (other than email once in 60 days), turn off you phone on the next Mother's Day,  do not expect to speak to either of them anytime soon, refuse to give your approval, etc. That is fine when this is what you truly want in your heart and it works for you and makes you happy in the end. I just wonder if part of it is reacting to the treatment you have been subjected to and is therefore coming from the resentment you might feel.

I agree with you I've gone through a lot of pain, I wouldn't be on this website if that wasn't the case.

As for setting down boundaries, in terms of words, etc., that's a total waste of time with people who are toxic.  They will twist your words and message and it's just another piece of "ammunition" for the "we are so hard done by dept.".

The type of behaviour that I've been dealing with for almost 2 years is abusive.  Not financially abusive because I didn't let it happen.  Emotionally abusive, without a doubt and with malice from them both.  I don't think I'm reacting to the treatment, except in a way to protect myself.  I don't see myself as resentful, I see myself as putting up the barriers to protect myself from any further abuse.

I don't believe you undo a lifetime of conditioning on the part of my future DIL's family to expect the universe to revolve around her and to have everyone else in her life pick up the tab for ridiculous extravagance.  I've never known anyone to buy 10 nightgowns at a time, well, maybe Jackie O.  Just another day for her.

The difficult part is that I have come, and am still working on coming to terms with is that the relationship that I had with my son and her is over.  The relationship as I knew it.  If there is to be a new relationship, it will be forget over time and it is unlikely that I will ever trust them 100% again.  I can think of many sets of circumstances where their best interests were what they were interested in at the expense of my best interests.  Toxic.  This is not the way that people who truly care about you treat you.  (If you allow them to)

If I afford them the opportunity to keep in touch with me from a minimal point of view, that's still more than I have to.  I could, if I chose, walk away completely and wish them well in their marriage and future and "drive on".  I've chosen not to do that.  I've chosen to make it clear to them/her in actions that any controlling type behaviour will be met with a wall of silence.  Actions speak louder than words.

This isn't much different from an abusive relationship where a husband batters a woman into submission.  The players have slightly different roles, but it is still a family setting where a victim (that would be me, and in a way, my son) submit to the constant, unreasonable demands of a perpetrator (my future DIL) who will never be pleased no matter what.

If my son has chosen to marry her, put up with her and take the consequences, so be it.  I never agreed to put up with this.  After more than 5 years of treating her with every courtesy, kindness, and a generous heart in every way, that department is closed.  It is closed because of their bad behavior.  Those are their consequences and if they don't like it, tough luck.

It's been agony for me to realize that my son (who up until 2 years ago) treated me with every courtesy, respect and wouldn't take a nickel from me has not been turned into this resentful, cold, perhaps even hateful individual.  He has morphed into someone that I need to protect myself from.  Very, very sad, but the writing is on the wall and I'm not going to ignore it.

Giving them "wiggle room" is foolhardy in my opinion, that's like giving a bullet to someone who has a gun instead of a dozen bullets.  If you are a mature adult you don't need "wiggle room", which is just another form of indulgence that parents have given these spoiled brats.  You need to GROW UP and act like an adult.  Stand on your own two feet, and when YOU have been emotionally abusive to someone who has given you nothing but kindness and generosity for 5 years, the apologies should be coming my way from them both.

I'm no longer in the behavior modification department, my years of raising a child are over.  I'm in the "getting on with my life, and having a great time" timeframe.  If I don't allow them a reply for 60 days it's because I don't need the toxic kids to spray their toxicity more frequently, because they are resentful and angry that they won't be treated like the Princess and her Prince and wish to "punish" me for not recognizing what they deserve.  THEIR expectations are the problem, totally outlandish and unlikely to change while anyone else continues to meet them.

There is no room in my life/heart for toxic people.  That I've even decided to leave a sliver of opportunity to keep in touch with me is all that I'm prepared to do and I'm totally fine with that.  They are lucky to have that but I'm sure won't appreciate that either.  Maybe down the line, but I'm not counting on that any more than I'm counting on winning the lottery to buy my groceries this week.

Change is difficult for everyone, and it is impossible to motivate anyone but yourself.   My expectations are "0" for a relationship with them.  If something better materializes, it's a bonus, if not, I'm ready for it.
“There will always be rocks in the road ahead of us. They will be stumbling blocks or stepping stones; it all depends on how you use them.”
Friedrich Nietzsche

barelythere

  • Guest
Re: Advice needed - Future daughter-in-law is allowing contact only via her
« Reply #61 on: August 01, 2010, 08:11:49 AM »
I sense a lot of pain from you posts.  Behind all the toughness and ruggedness, there is a person that is vulnerable and that has been hurt a lot. I am sorry for the injustice that has happened to you. I am glad to see however that you know you are able to take good care of yourself.
I think it was your absolute right to refuse to pay for the ring or pitch in for the wedding and that your decision ought to have been respected. You have done all your best bringing up your child and he is responsible for himself now.

As for the ultimatum, I agree with 1Glitterati. Ultimatums only work if you follow through completely and you have let go of the outcome. Meaning that you will be able to accept whatever the outcome will be.
Life is not black and white, people are not black and white and all-or-nothing approach can leave us soon lonely. To set the consequences for unacceptable behavior is completely ok and can also be done in other ways.

For instance:

If you break your plans with me by not showing up or by calling me at the last minute to tell me that you had something else come up, I will confront your behavior and share my feelings. If you repeat that behavior, I will consider it to mean that you do not value or deserve my friendship - and I will have no contact with you for a month.

Since behavior patterns are quite ingrained in all of us, it is important to allow the other person some wiggle room to make a change in behavior - unless the behavior is really intolerable.  To go from one extreme to the other is a reaction to a reaction - and is codependent.  There are choices in between which are sometimes hard for us to see if we are reacting.  It is helpful to set boundaries that allow for some gradual change.

The consequences we set down for behavior we find unacceptable should be realistic - in that, the change that we are asking for is something that is within the others power (rather they are willing to take that responsibility is another thing altogether) - and enforceable, something that we are willing to do.

I read you have decided not to share your vulnerabilities with them, have no contact (other than email once in 60 days), turn off you phone on the next Mother's Day,  do not expect to speak to either of them anytime soon, refuse to give your approval, etc. That is fine when this is what you truly want in your heart and it works for you and makes you happy in the end. I just wonder if part of it is reacting to the treatment you have been subjected to and is therefore coming from the resentment you might feel.

I agree with you I've gone through a lot of pain, I wouldn't be on this website if that wasn't the case.

As for setting down boundaries, in terms of words, etc., that's a total waste of time with people who are toxic.  They will twist your words and message and it's just another piece of "ammunition" for the "we are so hard done by dept.".

The type of behaviour that I've been dealing with for almost 2 years is abusive.  Not financially abusive because I didn't let it happen.  Emotionally abusive, without a doubt and with malice from them both.  I don't think I'm reacting to the treatment, except in a way to protect myself.  I don't see myself as resentful, I see myself as putting up the barriers to protect myself from any further abuse.

I don't believe you undo a lifetime of conditioning on the part of my future DIL's family to expect the universe to revolve around her and to have everyone else in her life pick up the tab for ridiculous extravagance.  I've never known anyone to buy 10 nightgowns at a time, well, maybe Jackie O.  Just another day for her.

The difficult part is that I have come, and am still working on coming to terms with is that the relationship that I had with my son and her is over.  The relationship as I knew it.  If there is to be a new relationship, it will be forget over time and it is unlikely that I will ever trust them 100% again.  I can think of many sets of circumstances where their best interests were what they were interested in at the expense of my best interests.  Toxic.  This is not the way that people who truly care about you treat you.  (If you allow them to)

If I afford them the opportunity to keep in touch with me from a minimal point of view, that's still more than I have to.  I could, if I chose, walk away completely and wish them well in their marriage and future and "drive on".  I've chosen not to do that.  I've chosen to make it clear to them/her in actions that any controlling type behaviour will be met with a wall of silence.  Actions speak louder than words.

This isn't much different from an abusive relationship where a husband batters a woman into submission.  The players have slightly different roles, but it is still a family setting where a victim (that would be me, and in a way, my son) submit to the constant, unreasonable demands of a perpetrator (my future DIL) who will never be pleased no matter what.

If my son has chosen to marry her, put up with her and take the consequences, so be it.  I never agreed to put up with this.  After more than 5 years of treating her with every courtesy, kindness, and a generous heart in every way, that department is closed.  It is closed because of their bad behavior.  Those are their consequences and if they don't like it, tough luck.

It's been agony for me to realize that my son (who up until 2 years ago) treated me with every courtesy, respect and wouldn't take a nickel from me has not been turned into this resentful, cold, perhaps even hateful individual.  He has morphed into someone that I need to protect myself from.  Very, very sad, but the writing is on the wall and I'm not going to ignore it.

Giving them "wiggle room" is foolhardy in my opinion, that's like giving a bullet to someone who has a gun instead of a dozen bullets.  If you are a mature adult you don't need "wiggle room", which is just another form of indulgence that parents have given these spoiled brats.  You need to GROW UP and act like an adult.  Stand on your own two feet, and when YOU have been emotionally abusive to someone who has given you nothing but kindness and generosity for 5 years, the apologies should be coming my way from them both.

I'm no longer in the behavior modification department, my years of raising a child are over.  I'm in the "getting on with my life, and having a great time" timeframe.  If I don't allow them a reply for 60 days it's because I don't need the toxic kids to spray their toxicity more frequently, because they are resentful and angry that they won't be treated like the Princess and her Prince and wish to "punish" me for not recognizing what they deserve.  THEIR expectations are the problem, totally outlandish and unlikely to change while anyone else continues to meet them.

There is no room in my life/heart for toxic people.  That I've even decided to leave a sliver of opportunity to keep in touch with me is all that I'm prepared to do and I'm totally fine with that.  They are lucky to have that but I'm sure won't appreciate that either.  Maybe down the line, but I'm not counting on that any more than I'm counting on winning the lottery to buy my groceries this week.

Change is difficult for everyone, and it is impossible to motivate anyone but yourself.   My expectations are "0" for a relationship with them.  If something better materializes, it's a bonus, if not, I'm ready for it.

Your strength gives me such courage!  Please keep writing.  I too have been devastated by a selfish woman who doesn't want to be a family but who wants to be catered to at all cost, even our lives if necessary.  I've seen my son morph into a cold and uncaring person.  He was the most tenderhearted individual in the world.  This is so hard to get through.  I know it is none of my business but it hurts and I need courage to break free.  It is not easy for a Mother to just say let go and be done with it.  Thank you, Keys Girl, thank you!

cremebrulee

  • Guest
Re: Advice needed - Future daughter-in-law is allowing contact only via her
« Reply #62 on: August 01, 2010, 08:16:30 AM »
I agree barethere...you give strength to all of us...
and think your attitude is very healthy...your experience is indeed very painful...I have a girlfriend like you...she has very very good repour with all of her DIL's...she is very forgiving, however, she will not allow anyone to use her for a doormat...and she told me that once...that I needed to stop trying to appease everyone and please myself for once...
to just be myself...thank God for her and these women in here...they all helped me a great deal...and even though my DIL and I are now on speaking terms...I have learned to respect her...however, I still want to learn...that is why I'm still coming in this forum...and to also, if I can, help others not to make the same mistakes I did...

please do keep writing...b/c you have a lot to offer and share others...a whole lot...
thank you
Creme

Alicev

  • Guest
Re: Advice needed - Future daughter-in-law is allowing contact only via her
« Reply #63 on: August 01, 2010, 08:45:22 AM »

I know that in relationships we often wish that the other person would change. This wish is wasted: we simply cannot change the other person, no matter how hard we try. It's quite a burden to be in charge of others. It feels like our work is never done when our intent is in controlling the actions and words of others. It's exhausting work, too, since our efforts are consistently futile.

It looks to me that you have chosen to detach, which I think is a very healthy way to take care of yourself.

This is an excerpt from Fearless relationships by Karen Casey:

By detaching, we can let go of the opinions and actions of others, recognizing that they reflect the other person and never us. We can allow others to be who they want to be without the complications of our judgements. When we judge others we compromise out ability to make the right choices for our own journey. Detaching with love allows us the opportunity for growth that we deserve. It lets others be alone without condemning them and without creating unnecessary work for ourselves. It conveys in its own language, "You are free to be you. I am here if you want my help."

The gift of this rule is that we avoid getting into the minds of others, a place we have no business being. It is not our job to be anyone else's decision maker, judge, or Higher Power. Each of us has roles to play in other people's lives. However, that doesn't give us license to attach ourselves to the intricacies of each other's journeys. We are sharing this path, nothing more. We honor other people when we let them make their own choices. Each person's journey is specific, we must not interfere. Detachment frees us. Detachment lets us be in charge of ourselves. Detachment is not indifference. Detachment is a lesson common to all of us.

cremebrulee

  • Guest
Re: Advice needed - Future daughter-in-law is allowing contact only via her
« Reply #64 on: August 01, 2010, 09:57:49 AM »
can you image Faith, if we could all live by this...what a wonderful world it would be...there would be no wars...no hate, no corruption...nothing but  complete harmony....to realize this, is a milestone...

Thank you

Offline catchingup

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 210
    • View Profile
Re: Advice needed - Future daughter-in-law is allowing contact only via her
« Reply #65 on: August 01, 2010, 10:12:25 AM »
Darling the older we are the closer we are to that---"HEAVEN" 8)

Offline catchingup

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 210
    • View Profile
Re: Advice needed - Future daughter-in-law is allowing contact only via her
« Reply #66 on: August 01, 2010, 10:15:39 AM »
No, I don't need to tell her anything.......she knows.....my son would have told her last year after I read him the "riot act".  That's why she's so mad.....she knows and I suspect that underneath that hostility is a certain mix of envy and jealousy and anger because I won't give her my "goodhousekeeping seal of approval" before she marries my son.  My son isn't getting any medals from me either these days, so they are in it together, a united front of resentment and "so there".....well the peace and quiet department is open again at my house......"so there".  Writing to a magazine, etc. is bad behaviour on my part, I would rather post here and try to help people instead of looking for sympathy.  That stuff always comes back to bite you.



Every once in a while I feel sorry for her, she is so controlling, and tiresome because she's really looking for attention and approval, but that's not going to get me feeling sorry for her......she'll do with bad attention rather than good attention or no attention.

Putting me in the "dog house" is a nasty thing to do....but considering that the "dog house" might have a lock on the inside and I could stay inside as long as I want, they could find themselves in the "be careful what you wish for category".  My wish is to carry on with my life and enjoy it as much as possible.  I don't owe anyone anything, I owe myself the best possible years for however many I have left.

I have altered my plans for the wedding.  Instead of showing up with some big, ugly dude, I will show up with a much younger, handsome man.  Another friend of mine has the whole "duty wedding" and that's what she's doing.  I'll do that too.

"Said I was giving you bad advise" Did not mean it to be serious.
« Last Edit: August 01, 2010, 10:26:00 AM by catchingup »

Offline catchingup

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 210
    • View Profile
Re: Advice needed - Future daughter-in-law is allowing contact only via her
« Reply #67 on: August 01, 2010, 10:21:34 AM »
I love the idea of your showing up at the wedding with a hunk, dude, fox, hottie  or whatever the current term is. We all know what you mean!  :o  And we can all picture it!   ;D ;D Way to go!!!  8)
If I can achieve what Luise has achieved at her "Magnificiant" age I will have achieved a lot.
Just the right person to run this site---Lovely sense of humour which we all need added sometimes.

Alicev

  • Guest
Re: Advice needed - Future daughter-in-law is allowing contact only via her
« Reply #68 on: August 01, 2010, 10:27:21 AM »
Quote
can you image Faith, if we could all live by this...what a wonderful world it would be...there would be no wars...no hate, no corruption...nothing but  complete harmony....to realize this, is a milestone...

Thank you


I don't know about all people. But I know that each day is new whether we believe it or not. The miracle isn't that the chance is there: it has always been there. The miracle is what happens when we reach out to embrace it. As long there is life, there is a chance to start over.
« Last Edit: August 01, 2010, 10:59:08 AM by Faith »

Offline Keys Girl

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 319
  • photo courtesy of Suat Eman
    • View Profile
Re: Advice needed - Future daughter-in-law is allowing contact only via her
« Reply #69 on: August 01, 2010, 10:46:56 AM »
I think that "detachment" is the way to go.  The word itself hadn't popped into my brain but that's what I am striving for.

I am not rejecting, I am not disapproving, but I am not going to be anyone's target for hostility and resentment anymore.

As the old saying goes, if you want to change the output you have to change the input.  I'm not sure exactly what the output will be but I will certainly make sure that my interests are taken care of by me.

“There will always be rocks in the road ahead of us. They will be stumbling blocks or stepping stones; it all depends on how you use them.”
Friedrich Nietzsche

Offline Pen

  • Global Moderator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3017
    • View Profile
Re: Advice needed - Future daughter-in-law is allowing contact only via her
« Reply #70 on: August 01, 2010, 10:59:11 AM »
A dear friend of mine moved far away a few years ago...we no longer share the same daily experiences, etc., and when we talk or email once every year or so I realize that although we're still friends, and have fond memories of times past, we've moved on. It's OK, a natural part of life.

I am trying to see my DS more that way...at first I missed him so much it was almost impossible to bear. He's a great guy, and we'd always had wonderful times together. I always enjoyed discussing current events, history, politics, etc. with him, and we share a similar sense of humor that not everyone appreciates. To have lost my DS due to his marrying a controlling, unkind, shunning DIL is more difficult to overcome than the loss of a friend due to a long-distance move, but I know I can get through it. I refuse to allow DIL & her FOO ruin my life. They're not worth it.
Respect ... is appreciation of the separateness of the other person, of the ways in which he or she is unique.
-- Annie Gottlieb

Offline Barbie

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 287
    • View Profile
Re: Advice needed - Future daughter-in-law is allowing contact only via her
« Reply #71 on: August 01, 2010, 11:40:42 AM »
I know exactly how you feel.  My DS #1 and I were so close, we had the same interests, same sense of humor, same tastes, etc. and now we have nothing in common. I hate to say this but I don’t like being alone with him anymore, I feel so awkward when he’s around, I know I gave birth to him and yet it feels like he’s a stranger most of the times. He still calls me everyday and I know he’s trying to rebuild our relationship but it’s so hard after all that’s happened. I don’t understand what DIL’s think they gain from all this, it shows their lack of confidence and immaturity.
I hope things change for the better before too much more time is wasted on all this sillyness.

barelythere

  • Guest
Re: Advice needed - Future daughter-in-law is allowing contact only via her
« Reply #72 on: August 01, 2010, 11:48:21 AM »
I know exactly how you feel.  My DS #1 and I were so close, we had the same interests, same sense of humor, same tastes, etc. and now we have nothing in common. I hate to say this but I don’t like being alone with him anymore, I feel so awkward when he’s around, I know I gave birth to him and yet it feels like he’s a stranger most of the times. He still calls me everyday and I know he’s trying to rebuild our relationship but it’s so hard after all that’s happened. I don’t understand what DIL’s think they gain from all this, it shows their lack of confidence and immaturity.
I hope things change for the better before too much more time is wasted on all this sillyness.

Exactly, Guest1, my son won't be alone with me and when we are, we both feel very uncomfortable. He has a look of guilt on his face that he can't hide.  We used to have so much fun and so much in common, all the likes and dislikes.  It is just a shame. I am very humiliated for the world to see what everyone thought was the perfect home to not be.

Offline stilltryen

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 141
    • View Profile
Re: Advice needed - Future daughter-in-law is allowing contact only via her
« Reply #73 on: August 01, 2010, 12:25:02 PM »
I know exactly how you feel.  My DS #1 and I were so close, we had the same interests, same sense of humor, same tastes, etc. and now we have nothing in common. I hate to say this but I don’t like being alone with him anymore, I feel so awkward when he’s around, I know I gave birth to him and yet it feels like he’s a stranger most of the times. He still calls me everyday and I know he’s trying to rebuild our relationship but it’s so hard after all that’s happened. I don’t understand what DIL’s think they gain from all this, it shows their lack of confidence and immaturity.
I hope things change for the better before too much more time is wasted on all this sillyness.

Don't you find it encouraging that he still calls every day tho?  I'm okay with my DIL, evidently we're never going to be the great friends I thought once we might be, but DS comes over and we either chat on the phone or via computer a lot.  I never, ever bring up DIL.  If he says anything, I respond as non-committal as possible and try to change the subject.  I want him to know that we're always here for the both of them if they need anything, but no, we're not going to bother them, drop by unexpectedly, etc.  One can only do what one can and let the chips fall where they may.

Offline Barbie

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 287
    • View Profile
Re: Advice needed - Future daughter-in-law is allowing contact only via her
« Reply #74 on: August 01, 2010, 01:31:22 PM »
The fact that he is committed to calling me everyday tells me that deep down he still cares and wants to have a relationship with his family and yes, it gives me a shred of hope that someday we'll be able to work out our differences but DIL holds all the cards. We haven’t meddled in our kid’s lives since they were in college and this is another line that she uses, that we didn’t care enough about him because we hardly ever visited him while in college and her mother used to visit her often. According to DIL we didn’t do anything right, but we raised him and he was good enough to marry. Go figure